
The Plymouth South Beach
Best for culture-and-design seekers who want South Beach steps from museums and nightlife.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Plymouth South Beach is a 4–4.5★ Art Moderne boutique hotel in the Collins Park/Museum District, good for travelers who want a walkable South Beach location, design-forward rooms, and easy beach access. Carillon Miami Wellness Resort is a 5★ luxury, wellness-forward beachfront resort in North Beach for travelers prioritizing on-site spa programming, fitness classes, and wellness facilities.
Updated · about 3.5 miles apart

Best for culture-and-design seekers who want South Beach steps from museums and nightlife.

Best for guests who want a resort focused on spa, fitness classes, and beachtime at a full-service wellness property.
When The Plymouth South Beach wins: choose The Plymouth if you want an Art Deco boutique stay steps from The Bass, easy access to Lincoln Road and South Beach nightlife, and a smaller, design-focused property with private beach transfers.
When Carillon Miami Wellness Resort wins: pick Carillon if your priority is comprehensive on-site wellness — a full-service spa, multiple fitness and Pilates/Yoga classes, two outdoor pools and multiple hot tubs, and direct beachfront access.
Bottom line: both suit beach-minded, wellness-aware travelers, but The Plymouth is a compact, culture-centric South Beach boutique with limited spa services, while Carillon is a larger, spa-forward luxury resort built around wellness offerings and beachfront access.
| Category | The Plymouth South Beach | Carillon Miami Wellness Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique Art Moderne, museum-district location, smaller scale | Luxury, spa-and-wellness–focused beachfront resort |
| Location | Collins Park / Bass Museum — South Beach (a few blocks to the sand) | North Beach beachfront on Collins Ave (direct beach access) |
| Size (rooms) | ~109–116 rooms | 150 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | Family-friendly; children welcome | All-ages property (wellness focus) |
| Pools & hot tubs | One outdoor Art Deco-style pool with loungers, poolside service/cabanas (surcharge) | Two outdoor pools and 2 hot tubs plus sauna; pool sun loungers and poolside bar |
| Restaurants & bars | Blue Ribbon Sushi Bar & Grill, Seasons Café, 2 bars/pool bar | 2 restaurants, 1 bar/lounge, coffee shop; room service (limited hours) |
| Wellness & fitness | 24-hour fitness center, fitness classes, beach yoga; spa-style massages and beauty services for a fee | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments, facials; on-site Pilates and yoga classes and broad wellness programming |
| Beach access | Private Plymouth Beach transfer (complimentary daytime transfer) to a private patch of South Beach a couple blocks away | Beachfront with beach loungers, umbrellas, beach yoga on site |
| Accessibility & family services | Accessible features documented; babysitting/childcare available (surcharge) | Wheelchair-accessible features; supervised childcare/activities (surcharge) |
| Parking & logistics | Valet parking (surcharge); EV charging station noted; resort fee applies | Valet parking (surcharge); secured parking, limo/town car service available |
The Plymouth sits on Collins Park across from The Bass and is a short walk to Lincoln Road and the Convention Center.
Choose The Plymouth for easy pedestrian access to South Beach culture, restaurants, and shopping.
Carillon occupies beachfront frontage in North Beach, putting sand and ocean at guests’ doorstep.
Choose Carillon if you want a beachfront stay with more resort-style beach time and wellness programming.
The Plymouth’s roughly 109–116 guestrooms range from Classic rooms to multi-bedroom suites with terraces.
The Plymouth is best for travelers who want boutique, design-led rooms within a compact hotel layout.
Carillon lists 150 guestrooms including One- and Two-Bedroom Luxury Apartment-style units with kitchens and balconies.
Carillon suits guests who want apartment-style rooms and more space, useful for longer stays or families.
The Plymouth has onboard options centered on Blue Ribbon Sushi Bar & Grill and a casual Seasons Café.
The Plymouth offers strong, compact dining choices—particularly for Japanese cuisine and poolside casual meals.
Carillon offers two restaurants, a coffee shop, and bar/lounge options with daily breakfast (fee applies) and room service during limited hours.
Carillon provides resort-style dining spread across multiple outlets, paired with room service and poolside options.
The Plymouth’s single outdoor Art Deco-style pool provides 24-hour access and a compact courtyard setting.
The Plymouth’s pool is stylish and central to the hotel’s social life but is small compared with full resort pools.
Carillon features two outdoor pools, two hot tubs and on-site beachfront space for a broader resort swim-and-sand experience.
Carillon is the better pick for guests who want multiple pool options plus immediate beach access.
The Plymouth offers spa-style massages and beauty services for a fee, plus a 24-hour fitness center and fitness classes.
The Plymouth supports basic wellness and fitness but is not a spa-centric resort. It's better for guests mixing culture, the beach, and casual wellness.
Carillon is positioned as a wellness resort with a full-service spa and on-site Pilates, yoga, and fitness classes.
Carillon is the clear choice for travelers focused on structured wellness programming and a comprehensive spa experience.

Carillon — full-service spa, Pilates and yoga classes on site, sauna/steam and multiple pools.

The Plymouth — across from The Bass and a short walk to Lincoln Road, Convention Center, and South Beach hotspots.

Carillon — One- and Two-Bedroom Luxury Apartment units with kitchens and larger living space.

The Plymouth — Art Moderne/Art Deco design, Restoration Hardware furnishings and a compact, stylish property.
Carillon — it’s a full-service wellness resort with a larger spa, multiple treatment types, and structured classes. The Plymouth offers spa-style massages and beauty services but not a large, branded spa.
The Plymouth — located in the Collins Park/Museum District only a short walk from Lincoln Road, the Convention Center, and South Beach venues.
The Plymouth is family-friendly and welcomes children of all ages; Carillon also lists supervised childcare/activities (surcharge) but is marketed primarily as a luxury wellness resort.
Yes. Carillon is beachfront with on-site beach loungers and umbrellas; The Plymouth provides a complimentary daytime transfer to a private Plymouth Beach area a couple blocks from the hotel.
Explore how The Plymouth South Beach stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·