
The Plymouth South Beach
Best for families and design-minded travelers who want an Art Deco stay with a courtyard pool, on-site Japanese dining, and private daytime beach transfers.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Plymouth South Beach is a family-friendly, Art Moderne/Art Deco boutique hotel across from The Bass in Collins Park; The Villa Casa Casuarina is the historic luxury boutique in the former Versace Mansion on Ocean Drive. Read this if you want a side-by-side look at a museum-district, design-forward stay (Plymouth) versus a small, celebrity-famous mansion hotel (Casa Casuarina).
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for families and design-minded travelers who want an Art Deco stay with a courtyard pool, on-site Japanese dining, and private daytime beach transfers.

Best for travelers seeking a compact, high‑design hotel with celebrity history and individually named suites in a mansion setting near Ocean Drive.
When The Plymouth South Beach wins: choose the Plymouth if you want more rooms and event space, 24-hour fitness, family-friendly policies, on-site restaurants (Blue Ribbon Sushi Bar & Grill and Seasons Café), and a private beach transfer that makes beach time easy for groups and families.
When The Villa Casa Casuarina wins: choose Casa Casuarina if you want a small, historic mansion experience tied to Gianni Versace and prefer staying in a handful of distinctive suites with direct access to Ocean Drive and the South Beach promenade.
Bottom line: pick Plymouth for a full-service, family-friendly Art Deco hotel with more onsite amenities and event options; pick Villa Casa Casuarina for a compact, celebrity-famous luxury stay where the building and suites are the main attraction.
| Category | The Plymouth South Beach | The Villa Casa Casuarina |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Art Moderne/Art Deco boutique, museum-district feel | Historic luxury mansion with a strong celebrity backstory |
| Location | Collins Park / Museum District, one block from The Bass and a short walk to the beach | Ocean Drive address in South Beach, steps from the boardwalk and beach |
| Size (rooms) | About 109–116 rooms | 10 rooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages; family-friendly (kids policies and babysitting available) | All ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools | One outdoor Art Deco-style courtyard pool (24-hour access reported on some listings) | Number of outdoor pools - 1 (mansion pool) |
| Restaurants & bars | Blue Ribbon Sushi Bar & Grill, Seasons Café, plus two bars/lounges | One restaurant and one bar/lounge listed; room service available (limited hours) |
| Spa & fitness | 24-hour fitness center, fitness classes and paid spa services (massage, hair/makeup) available | Spa: Not published |
| Known for | Art Deco design, Restoration Hardware–furnished rooms, family-friendly amenities and event spaces | Former Versace Mansion, individually named luxury suites and mansion architecture |
| Event & meeting space | Multiple indoor/outdoor venues (several event spaces; max reception capacity listed up to 600 across spaces) | Banquet hall and meeting rooms available (smaller, mansion-style event options) |
| Transport & beach access | Complimentary daytime transfers to private Plymouth Beach; close to convention center and cultural venues | Steps from Ocean Drive and Miami Beach Boardwalk; close to Collins Avenue shopping |
The Plymouth sits in Collins Park and the Museum District, directly across from The Bass museum and a short walk from the convention center.
Choose the Plymouth for a museum-district base with easy access to cultural venues and a nearby private beach transfer.
The Villa Casa Casuarina sits on Ocean Drive in South Beach, placing you right on the promenade with quick access to the boardwalk and beach.
Choose Casa Casuarina for immediate Ocean Drive access and staying at a beach-facing historic mansion.
The Plymouth offers a broad room mix across a four-story Art Moderne/Art Deco building with design-focused interiors.
Plymouth works better for travelers who want a larger selection of room types, family configurations, and consistent Art Deco design.
Villa Casa Casuarina is a small mansion hotel with a short list of individually named suites and distinctive layouts.
Casa Casuarina is for travelers who prefer a small number of highly individual suites and a mansion‑style stay rather than a large hotel inventory.
The Plymouth keeps dining local and varied with a full-service sushi restaurant plus a casual café and bars.
Plymouth offers reliable, varied on-site dining options for families and groups without leaving the property.
Villa Casa Casuarina lists one restaurant and a bar/lounge; room service is available during limited hours.
Casa Casuarina is better if you want an intimate, mansion-style dining experience tied to the property rather than multiple restaurants.
The Plymouth centers around an Art Deco courtyard pool and includes private beach transfers and cabana options.
Plymouth is oriented around a central courtyard pool plus a private beach transfer, a practical setup for families and groups.
Villa Casa Casuarina lists one outdoor pool in a mansion setting and offers poolside lounging typical of a small boutique property.
Casa Casuarina provides a single mansion pool and direct access to the Ocean Drive beachfront rather than resort-style pool facilities.
Plymouth provides fitness classes and paid spa services, plus easy access to cultural nightlife and events nearby.
Choose Plymouth if you want on-site fitness, bookable spa treatments, and easy access to cultural venues and organized fitness offerings.
Casa Casuarina offers an intimate mansion experience; spa information isn’t published in the supplier listing.
Casa Casuarina is suited to guests who prioritize the mansion setting and Ocean Drive nightlife over an extensive on-site wellness program.

The Plymouth — family-friendly policies, babysitting services, multiple room configurations, and private beach transfers.

The Villa Casa Casuarina — stay in the former Versace Mansion with individually named suites and mansion character.

The Plymouth — Blue Ribbon Sushi plus a café and two bars; more options without leaving the property.

The Villa Casa Casuarina — very small room inventory and mansion-style suites for a compact, private feel.
The Villa Casa Casuarina — it sits on Ocean Drive steps from the boardwalk; Plymouth is a short walk from Ocean Drive but in the Collins Park museum district.
The Plymouth — documented family-friendly policies, childcare services for a surcharge, and room types that accommodate children.
The supplier listing does not publish a named spa; spa details are not published in the provided listing.
Yes — both are within easy walking distance of Lincoln Road shopping and South Beach attractions, with Casa Casuarina on Ocean Drive and Plymouth in the Museum District.
Explore how The Plymouth South Beach stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·