
The Plymouth South Beach
Best for travelers who want a smaller, design-driven South Beach hotel steps from The Bass and Collins Park.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Plymouth South Beach is a 4–4.5★ Art Moderne boutique in Collins Park with an on-site Japanese restaurant, courtyard pool and private beach transfers — good for travelers who want a compact, design-forward South Beach base near museums. The Shelborne By Proper is an upscale, 4.5★ beachfront resort on Collins Avenue with more rooms, larger meeting capacity and a Proper lifestyle profile — best for travelers who want direct beach access and a resort-scale South Beach stay.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for travelers who want a smaller, design-driven South Beach hotel steps from The Bass and Collins Park.

Best for travelers who prioritize beachfront rooms, private beach access and resort-level meeting/amenity space.
When The Plymouth South Beach wins: choose Plymouth if you want a smaller Art Deco/Art Moderne boutique with a central Collins Park/Museum District address, courtyard pool and on-site Blue Ribbon Sushi for dinner without walking to Collins Avenue.
When The Shelborne By Proper wins: choose The Shelborne if you need direct beachfront access, more on-site bars and restaurants, a larger meeting footprint, or prefer a resort with a wider range of ocean-view room types.
Bottom line: Plymouth is the pick for a compact, culture‑adjacent South Beach boutique stay; Shelborne is the pick for a beachfront, resort-scale experience with more rooms and event space.
| Category | The Plymouth South Beach | The Shelborne By Proper |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small Art Moderne boutique; design-focused | Upscale beachfront resort with Proper lifestyle profile |
| Location | Collins Park / Museum District (across from The Bass), a couple blocks from the sand | Directly on Collins Avenue, on a private stretch of Miami Beach |
| Size (guest rooms) | About 109–116 rooms | 251 rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; main guest must be 21 to check in | |
| Pools | One outdoor Art Deco courtyard pool (24-hour access listed) | Outdoor pool plus private beach access and pool cabanas |
| Restaurants & bars | Blue Ribbon Sushi Bar & Grill, Seasons Café, 2 bars/lounges | Pauline (restaurant) + café, 3 bars/lounges, pool/beach bars |
| Spa / wellness | Spa services available (no single published branded spa name) | Wheelchair‑accessible spa available (spa name not published) |
| Known for | Art Moderne design, proximity to The Bass and cultural venues | Beachfront location and Proper/Design Hotels branding |
| Meetings & events | Multiple small/medium event spaces; overall reception capacity up to 600 | About 30,000 sq ft conference space, 6 meeting rooms |
| Beach access | Private beach transfers to a Plymouth beach area two blocks away; beach cabanas for a surcharge | On a private beach with beach cabanas and beach umbrellas |
The Plymouth sits in the Museum District across from The Bass and a short walk to the Convention Center and Lincoln Road.
Choose Plymouth for immediate access to South Beach’s museum and cultural corridor rather than direct ocean frontage.
The Shelborne is sited directly on Collins Avenue with private beach access and easy boardwalk access.
Choose Shelborne if you want to be on the sand with straightforward beach and boardwalk access.
Plymouth’s roughly 109–116 rooms emphasize Art Moderne design and several terrace/terrace‑suite layouts.
Plymouth is best when you want a design-forward boutique room mix and a few larger suite options.
Shelborne’s 251 rooms cover city views, partial oceanfront and full oceanfront categories plus multi-room suites.
Shelborne offers more ocean-view rooms and a wider range of suite and villa-style options for groups or families.
The Plymouth has a compact, well-known dining lineup centered on Blue Ribbon and poolside café fare.
Plymouth suits guests who want a strong single signature dining option plus poolside and lobby café choices.
Shelborne lists Pauline as its main restaurant and supports multiple bars and beach/pool outlets.
Shelborne gives more bar and beach/pool dining variety for guests who plan to eat on-property.
Plymouth centers around a single Art Deco-style courtyard pool with 24-hour access noted in listings.
Plymouth’s pool is central to the hotel experience; beach is nearby via hotel transfer rather than immediate beachfront.
Shelborne offers an outdoor pool and direct private beach access immediately from the property.
Shelborne is preferable if you want to step directly from hotel to sand and use beach and pool amenities without a transfer.
Plymouth advertises a 24‑hour fitness center, fitness classes and spa services (pay per treatment).
Plymouth supports fitness routines and spa bookings within a quieter boutique setting; nightlife is easy to reach on foot.
Shelborne lists 24‑hour fitness, fitness classes on site and a wheelchair-accessible spa.
Shelborne provides full wellness and late-day beverage options at a slightly larger scale, plus direct beach access for active guests.

The Plymouth — steps from The Bass, Collins Park and South Beach’s museum cluster.

The Shelborne By Proper — direct private beach access and multiple ocean-view room types.

The Shelborne — about 30,000 sq ft of conference space and six meeting rooms for larger events.

The Plymouth — a compact Art Moderne property with design-led rooms and intimate event spaces.
The Plymouth South Beach — it sits across the street from The Bass and is in Collins Park’s museum district.
The Shelborne By Proper — it’s on Collins Avenue and lists private beach access and on-site beach amenities.
Yes. Both properties allow guests of all ages; the main guest checking in must be at least 21 at each hotel.
Shelborne has a larger conference footprint (about 30,000 sq ft and six meeting rooms), while Plymouth offers multiple smaller indoor/outdoor venues and an overall reception capacity cited up to 600 — choose based on the scale and style you want.
Explore how The Plymouth South Beach stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·